Your Pie Rewards
Express your inner pizza!



How much does Your Pie Rewards cost?
Prices are current as of 12 Nov 2026.
Your Pie Rewards has no in-app products on record in the United States.
10+ alternatives to Your Pie Rewards
![]() | ![]() | ![]() | ![]() | ![]() | ![]() | ![]() | ![]() | ![]() | ![]() | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rating / 5 | 4.8 | 4.8 | 4.7 | 4.8 | 4.9 | 4.9 | 4.8 | 4.9 | 4.7 | 4.4 | 2.9 |
| Reviews | 7.5K | 16K | 15K | 14K | 4.5K | 4.2K | 2.5K | 1.8K | 1.1K | 245 | 12 |
| Released | 2014 | 2020 | 2021 | 2015 | 2018 | 2022 | 2023 | 2026 | 2023 | 2015 | 2014 |
Your Pie Rewards reviews
4.8 out of 5, based on 7,463 reviews.
What people like
- Pizza is delicious and consistent
- Friendly and clean service
- Good value for the price
What they complain about
- App glitches make ordering impossible
- Forces you to save credit cards
- Login loops and frequent bugs
- No Apple Pay support
Lunch
Always a great experience
Love Your Pie, hate the new app
Your Pie is great! The old app was great! This new app that keeps badgering you to put in your credit card info… not so great. I use Apple Pay so it wouldn’t work anyway, but I don’t love the idea of putting my credit card info anywhere that isn’t a payment terminal or a known-PCI-Compliant platform like Stripe or Shopify. My info may be encrypted but they’ve got to have a way to match it to card swipes and that’s an instant NO for me. They’re also trying to dark pattern you into entering your card info whenever you scan receipts so that’s even worse. 0/10 wouldn’t recommend the app
Rewards system is flawed
They need to update how you can scan a receipt to get points when paying with cash, the current way is weird.
Clunky
Nowhere as good as some other chains - just clunky and not well designed. And, no Apple Pay.
Amesome
Great pizza for a reasonable price!
Rewards is Broken
The old app worked great, but the new one keeps me locked in a loop constantly trying to log in
Needs Improvement
Please fix the app so that it works with autocomplete. It would be nice if the app let you order everything that you can order in the restaurant. And not have such strict limitations on the toppings. It also needs the ability to properly manage credit cards. The first attempt to add my credit card said it was expired. But the real issue was that when I copied and pasted the number it had spaces in it that the field did not account for. I also did not see a way to remove or edit a credit card, and now it's hard for me to tell which one is in there correctly because I had to add it twice. It would also be nice if it accepted Apple Pay, which is much simpler.
Combo
I wish there was an option on the app to order a combo meal.
My new obsession
Absolutely love the pizza from Your Pie. Can’t get enough of it.
Rewards changed
Have to register a credit card to earn rewards. What idiot thought this was a good idea
App is confusing
Improve your app
Software Bugs
App was great but for the past few months it was unusable due to bugs. It’s now usable again but still has some issues.
War Eagle!
Kid tested, Father approved..
Why do they need my credit card?
It is ridiculous that they make you 1) save your credit card info in their system AND 2) use that particular card when ordering in order to earn points automatically. They allow you to go through the manual process of uploading receipts, but it is ridiculous they would force people to choose. What are they doing with the credit card info???
App could be better
Log in should use cell number instead of of email.
Awesome pizza, but app change locked me out of my account
Love the pizza but after they updated they app, I was logged out. And despite resetting my password 3 times , I'm unable to get back into my existing account . Hope that geys fixed so I get my existing points back
Megan Provost
We love Your Pie in Buford! They are always so kind and their food is delicious!
Terrible App
Absolutely abysmal ordering experience. The app is so glitchy it is not actually possible to place a curbside pickup order, even though the option is offered. The app simply doesn’t work.
Crashing
When trying to redeem points in store.
.
Excellent flavor, and the service is top notch , this place is always sparkling clean
Recent update
What an awful update and new ux. Couldn’t even order. Still awful
No way to pay
There’s no way to pay except Apple Pay so I couldn’t order on the app. Getting something else for dinner.
Love it
Always delicious and friendly service
Newest version stinks
The latest version of the app is unusable. Can’t get orders into the cart. Keeps you going in circles.
LOVE
My family loves eating here! Everything we have tried is so good!
Embarrassingly bad app
Terrible terrible app iphone 16e. Between the referral codes etc. I can’t even give them money for pizza. It says my own phone number is taken and I signed in with Apple!!!!! NEVER AGAIN GET YOUR PIZZA WHERE THEY WILL ACTUALLY DO BUSINESS!!!!!
My favorite pizza
Best pizza in the area
Deceiving
Barely any meat on their pizza. Deceiving.
Easy!
Easy to use!
Payment processing is glitchy
More than once ApplePay does not function and it won’t let me add a card outside for ApplePay to pay for my order.
Your Pie Rewards FAQ
- Is Your Pie Rewards free?
- Yes. The app is free, in all 1 country it sells in, and it sells nothing inside it.
- Does Your Pie Rewards have a free trial?
- No. None of its offers (US) come with a free trial.
- What are the best alternatives to Your Pie Rewards?
- Huey Magoo's (4.8 from 16,037 reviews), Krystal (4.7 from 14,681 reviews) and Parker's Rewards (4.8 from 13,939 reviews).
Your Pie Rewards download
Last updated 26 days ago.
Your Pie Rewards sells in 1 country. It was released 12 years and 10 months ago, on 11 Jan 2014. It holds a 4.8 rating from 7,463 reviews.
Supports 1 language: English.
How much does Your Pie Rewards make?
Third-party estimates for the last 30 days, worldwide — not the store's own figures, which Apple publishes for nobody.








